Kerala off-spinner Jalaj Saxena was miffed on Thursday with the “unfair” replacement of Gujarat’s concussed leg-spinner Ravi Bishnoi by seam-bowling all-rounder Hemang Patel in a decisive situation of the Ranji Trophy semi-final at the Narendra Modi Stadium.
With Gujarat batting for the crucial first-innings lead after the visitors were bowled out for 457 on Wednesday morning, Kerala were intimated of the inclusion of Bishnoi’s replacement post the day’s play. The India spinner injured his face and was left with a bloodied nose during fielding before walking off the field earlier on.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a6d77/a6d770c824768a980f35c7a0500a96e13a428b4e" alt=""
With Saxena snapping two wickets in the morning session, Gujarat sent Hemang at No. 5 ahead of the team’s leading run-scorer, Jaymeet Patel, and skipper Chintan Gaja.
Story continues below this ad
As the emerging concussion sub did not exactly sound by the ‘like-for-like replacement’ order of the law, Saxena was seen arguing Hemang’s entry at number five with the on-field umpire.
“Ravi Bishnoi is a bowler and he generally bats 9 or 10 for their side. And then as a concussion player, you are getting a player who bats really well and is promoted to bat number 5. I think that was unfair for us and that’s what I was telling the umpire. At least, if you have taken a batsman in place of him, make him play at number 11,” Saxena said.
Gujarat fielded Hemang after three other players on the bench – Kshitij Patel, Umang Kumar and Het Patel – posed stronger batting profiles. While Hemang’s 19.85 average from four previous First-Class outings – the lowest of the quartet – made his choice eligible, Saxena termed his inclusion unfair on Kerala. Putting on 27 runs off 41 balls, Hemang helped Gujarat regain momentum over Kerala to end the day with only a 29-run trail to seal the innings lead and potentially a final berth.
“He scored some crucial runs at that point and it was very visible that he wasn’t a bowler. He was a batsman who could bowl and not a like-for-like replacement for Bishnoi,” lamented Saxena.
Lalith Kalidas is a Senior Sub-Editor with the sports team of The Indian Express. Working with the online sports desk, Lalith specializes in the happenings on the cricket field, with a particular interest in India’s domestic cricket circle. He also carries an affinity towards data-driven stories and often weaves them into cricketing contexts through his analysis. Lalith also writes the weekly stats-based cricket column – ‘Stats Corner’. A former cricketer who has played in state-level tournaments in Kerala, he has over three years of experience as a sports journalist. Lalith also covered the 2023 ODI World Cup held in India. … Read More
© The Indian Express Pvt Ltd